Hierarchical ratings like Creative Loafing's are fun, but don't do much for me. It's too much like watching a Miss America Pageant or a very short reality show. "The Best" were not chosen by popular vote but by CL's own writers, who also create the categories.
Having said all that, congratulations to:
West Tampa Center for The Arts
USF's Contemporary Arts Museum
HCC Ybor Gallery and Performing Arts